New Action Figures. Fresh from the Case.
Straight off the truck, quality inspected, and ready for your shelf.
★★★★★ 4.94 average rating from 706+ verified collectors
Rated by real collectors who care how their figures arrive.
Carded Classics™ — Real Finds. Still on Card. Finally Back in the Wild.
Every item in Carded Classics™ comes straight from customer collections and includes photos of the actual figure you'll receive — so you know exactly what's headed to your shelf.
WWF Nailz Action Figure (1992)
WWF Crush Action Figure (1993)
WWF Kamala Action Figure (1993)
Join Hundreds of Collectors Who’ve Already Made Jay’s Their Go-To Shop
Let customers speak for us
This Is What Happens When Collectors Run the Shop.
Jay’s isn’t a faceless warehouse or a marketplace free-for-all. We’re a collector-run shop that’s been doing this long enough to know the difference between “good enough” and collector-grade.
Every order ships fast, gets packed with condition in mind, and is handled by people who actually care how it arrives — because we collect this stuff too. Action figures, cards, games, steelbooks — if it’s in your cart, it’s something we’d want showing up clean on our own shelf.
No gimmicks. No inflated hype. No crushed corners.
Just real inventory, honest condition, and a better way to buy collectibles online.