Jay’s Toys and Games · Sell by mail
Sell Nintendo games by mail.
NES, Super Nintendo, Nintendo 64 and GameCube games and consoles, plus Game Boy, DS, Switch and Switch 2. Boxed or loose. Send a list and photos, get a quote, and nothing ships until you’ve accepted it in writing.
Why sell to us.
-
Collectors buying from collectors.
The people quoting your games collect this stuff themselves. We’ve been buying since 2005: $12M+ paid out across 100,000+ transactions.
-
One quote for the whole lot.
No listing every cartridge one at a time, no answering messages from strangers, no packing dozens of separate boxes. One list, one quote, one shipment, one payment.
-
A quote built on real sales.
We work from recent sold listings and auction results, not an old price guide. No pressure either way: accept the quote or keep your collection.
-
Nothing ships until you say yes.
You see the quote and its terms first and accept them in writing. Until then your collection stays with you. On collections we value at $250 or more, we send the prepaid label.
-
Paid within 24 hours of sign-off.
PayPal, Venmo or a mailed check. The number we both sign off on is the number you’re paid.
-
A real shop behind the form.
Jay’s runs three brick-and-mortar stores in Iowa, open seven days a week, with a crew that handles collectibles every day.
What to tell us, system by system.
The details that make a quote accurate differ by system. These are the ones to include for each.

NES
- Labels. Tears, fading, writing or stickers on each cartridge label.
- Boxed games. List the dust sleeve, insert and manual for each box, if you have them.
- Battery saves. Games that save progress on the cartridge may no longer hold a save. Say if you know.
- Console. The original front-loader or the later top-loader, with controllers, AC adapter and the RF switch or AV cable. Say whether it powers on and reads games.

Super Nintendo
- Labels. Wear, writing or stickers on each cartridge label.
- Boxes. Super Nintendo boxes are cardboard. Note creases, tears and crushed corners, and list any inserts, maps or posters inside.
- Battery saves. Games that save on the cartridge may no longer hold a save. Say if you know.
- Console. The original model or the smaller later one, with controllers, AC adapter and AV cable. Say if the grey plastic has yellowed, and whether it powers on and reads games.

Nintendo 64
- Labels and boxes. Label wear on each cartridge. For boxed games, the cardboard box, the insert and the manual.
- Controllers. Say whether each analog stick is tight or loose.
- Paks. List any Controller Paks, Rumble Paks or Transfer Paks.
- Memory slot. Say whether the console has the Expansion Pak or the Jumper Pak in the slot on top.
- Console. AC adapter, AV cable and controllers. Say whether it powers on and reads games.

GameCube
- Discs. GameCube games are small discs. Note scratches on the playing side.
- Cases. Case, cover art and manual for each game. For two-disc games, say whether both discs are there.
- Memory cards. List them, with the size printed on each card.
- Console. Colour, controllers, AC adapter and AV cable. Say whether the lid closes and it reads discs, and list a Game Boy Player if one is attached underneath.

Game Boy family
- Model. Original Game Boy, Pocket, Color, Advance, Advance SP or Micro.
- Screen. Scratches on the screen cover, and any dead lines or dead pixels on the display.
- Battery cover and charging. Say whether the battery cover is there. For the SP and Micro, the charger and whether it holds a charge.
- Changes. Say if it has a replacement screen, backlight or shell.
- Cartridges. Label condition. Some games save on a battery inside the cartridge and may no longer hold a save.

DS
- Model. DS, DS Lite, DSi or DSi XL.
- Hinge and screens. Say if the hinge is cracked, note scratches on both screens, and whether the touch screen responds.
- Stylus and charger. Whether both are there, and whether it holds a charge.
- Games. Each game card with its case, cover art and manual, or loose.

Switch
- Model. Which Switch it is: the original, Lite, OLED or Switch 2.
- Joy-Con. List them, and say if a stick drifts (moves on its own).
- What comes with it. Dock, AC adapter and HDMI cable for the models that use them. Say whether it powers on and holds a charge, and sign out of your account before it ships.
- Games. The cartridge in its original case with the cover art. Sealed copies: say sealed.
How it works.
Seven steps. Nothing ships until you’ve accepted the quote in writing.
-
Send a list and photos
Tell us what you have through the form on this page. Email photos to selling@jaystoysandgames.com. The more detail, the closer the quote.
-
Get a quote
We reply with a quote, generally within 48 hours. It’s an initial offer and it isn’t binding yet.
-
Accept it in writing
You accept the quote and its terms in writing before anything ships. Nothing goes in a box until then.
-
Ship it
Collections we value at $250 or more get a prepaid shipping label from us. The quote says up front whether shipping is covered.
-
We check it
When the package arrives, we check that everything quoted is there and in the condition described.
-
Sign off, get paid
If it matches, we both sign off on the final number and you’re paid within 24 hours of that sign-off.
-
If it doesn’t match
Something missing or not in the stated condition gets you a revised offer. Decline it and we send the items back. You pay the return shipping.
What to put in the list.
- System and title. One line per game.
- Box, manual, inserts. For each game, say which you have. Loose cartridges are fine.
- Opened or cleaned. Say if a cartridge has been opened or its contacts cleaned.
- Reproductions. If you know a cartridge is a reproduction, say so.
- Tested or not. Say how you tested it. If you haven’t, say that.
What the photos should show.
- The whole lot in one wide shot, labels facing up.
- Each cartridge label close up, and the back of any cartridge with damage.
- Boxed games front and back, then opened with the manual and inserts beside them.
- Consoles and handhelds top and back, with the screen on if it powers up.
Send your list.
System, title, box and manual, tested or not. We reply with a quote, generally within 48 hours. The form takes text only. Email photos to selling@jaystoysandgames.com.
All video games by mail · PlayStation games · Sega games · Selling by mail: the overview
Near Des Moines? Bring it to a Jay’s CD and Hobby store







