WWE Elite CollectionMattel
Jay's Grade — our honest in-house call, not third-party slabbed.
WWE Elite Collection – CM Punk (Mattel Creations Exclusive) — Survivor Series: WarGames 2023 Return
Few moments in modern WWE history landed as hard as the closing seconds of Survivor Series: WarGames 2023 in Chicago — the opening riff of "Cult of Personality," the sold-out crowd erupting, and the Second City Saint walking back into a company he swore he'd never return to. This Mattel Creations exclusive Elite Collection figure exists solely to commemorate that landmark night, making it one of the most event-specific releases in the entire Elite line and an essential pickup for any serious CM Punk collector.
The figure captures Punk in his exact return look: white t-shirt and jeans, the outfit burned into the memory of everyone who watched that night live. Mattel's TRUE FX tattoo-detail technology brings his sleeve work to life with a level of accuracy that separates this release from standard mainline Elite figures. The window box itself is an event — the WarGames cage structure forms the backdrop behind the figure, the base panel carries the Chicago star logo, and the reverse features a full-bleed photo of Punk seated inside the cage at the actual PLE, flanked by the iconic "Hell Froze Over" tagline. This is a factory-sealed piece presented in excellent collectible condition.
As a Mattel Creations-exclusive drop, this figure sits firmly above the standard retail Elite tier — it was a limited online release tied to a single cultural moment rather than a recurring wave slot. Collectors building a complete CM Punk shelf will find this fills a specific gap that no mainline figure covers: the return, not the reign. Its packaging alone functions as a display piece, and the event-specific accessories and design choices reward the kind of collector who wants the story behind the plastic, not just the plastic itself.
Every graded piece is our honest in-house call — not third-party slabbed. Here's exactly where this one lands, and why.
This piece: CC-7 — Very Good
The grade is our word — the photos are the final word. Zoom in on every one before you buy.
Every order inspected and packed for the shelf — because we collect this stuff too.
In-stock orders go out fast. No weeks-long waits, no vague timelines.
Not what was described? We make it right. No arguments, no hassle.
Every review here is Judge.me–verified — no cherry-picking, no edits. Just collectors who got their figures mint instead of mangled, and came back to say so.
Jays is my first stop in collecting. I preorder things through Walmart, Amazon, Hasbro Pulse, etc., but Jays always seem to get the items and either meet or beat the other companies pricing. I always end up cancelling my pre-orders and going with Jays. Better selection, price and MUCH MUCH better shipping quality. You can't even compare anyone else's shipping and packing to Jays. And that's why Jay's blows them all out of the water.
Great fast shipping, packaging with care. I am definitely buying from Jay's again! Such peace of mind knowing my items will arrive minty. 5 stars!
Perfect and careful packaging, shipped super quick. Thank you, will definitely be following the store!
Didn't pull any punches in item description. Came extremely fast and well packed. Extremely happy being a first time buyer! Thank you.
I've been buying from Jay's for a while now and I am never disappointed with the experience. Prices that can't be beat, easy PayPal option, and lots of bubble wrap surrounding the products. The fact that they go out of their way to make consumers happy keeps me coming back.
This is my 3rd or 4th time I have ordered from Jay's. The orders are always correct and arrive pretty quick and packaged extremely well. Best in the industry.
Part of the line
Chasing the full set? See every WWE Elite Collection – Mattel Creations Exclusive figure we've got in stock.
Please read our FAQs page to find out more.
Most in-stock orders placed before 12 PM CST ship the same day. We’re label-printing, box-packing machines — without skimping on quality. Your tracking number will probably show up before you’ve even closed the tab.
Every item gets collector-grade treatment: bubble wrap, proper padding, and zero envelope crimes. We pack like your grail’s riding shotgun with us — damage rate is under 1%.
Yep. We’ve been hunting plastic treasures since the ‘90s. We speak fluent collector (MOC, BAF, grail hunting), we’ve camped outside stores for midnight releases, and we run this place like the shop we always wished existed. Professional enablers at your service. 😎
30 days to decide if it’s true love. Not happy? Full refund to your original payment method. Damaged? We replace or refund fast. Just keep items in the condition you got them, and we’ll make it right — because the only drama in collecting should be choosing a display pose. One exception: trading card game product is final sale, since a sealed box can’t be verified once it leaves our hands.
Calling dibs costs you $0 today — we only charge your card when it ships. No awkward “I paid months ago” limbo. Mixing in-stock + pre-orders? In-stock ships now; pre-orders ship together once the last one lands, and shipping’s charged on each leg (pro tip: check ship dates before combining pre-orders). Dates can shift — we’ll keep you posted faster than Spider-Man slings webs. And if we ever can’t deliver (rare), you’re not charged a dime.
Collectors Also Love
