Login

Before you sell a retro video game collection, it helps to know the words buyers use, what they need to see, and how to get a box of cartridges, discs and consoles across the country in one piece. This guide covers all three, then explains how selling by mail to Jay’s Toys and Games works, step by step.

The terms you will meet

Loose

A loose game is the cartridge or disc on its own, with no box and no manual. Loose games are still worth listing. For disc games, say whether you have the case and the manual, because “loose” can mean different things to different people.

Complete in box

Complete in box, often shortened to CIB, means the game, its box and its manual together. For some systems, boxes also held a plastic dust sleeve, a cardboard insert, a map or a poster. If your copy has those, list them too. If one piece is missing, say which one; “box, no manual” is much more useful to a buyer than “mostly complete”.

Sealed

Sealed means still in the original factory wrap and never opened. If a game is sealed, say so in your list and leave the wrap on. Note any tears in the wrap and any dents or creases in the box underneath.

Tested

Tested means someone has powered it on and confirmed it works. It is only useful if you say how. “Boots to the title screen” and “played through the first level, save holds” are different tests. For consoles, say whether it powers on, shows a picture and reads games. If you have not tested something, say that plainly. Untested is a normal answer and it helps more than a guess.

Reproduction

A reproduction is a copy of a game made by someone other than the original publisher, usually with a printed label made to look like the original. Some are sold openly as reproductions, and some get passed along as originals. If you know or suspect a cartridge is a reproduction, say so in the list. It saves a revised offer later.

Battery saves

Many cartridge games save progress to a small battery inside the cartridge. Those batteries are old now, and some no longer hold a save. If you know a game still saves, or has stopped saving, add it to the list.

How to take inventory

A clear list is what makes a quote accurate. Work one system at a time and write one line per game.

  • System and title. Group games by system.
  • What is included. For each game: box, manual, both or neither, and any inserts.
  • Condition. Label wear, writing or stickers, cracked cases, disc scratches, yellowed plastic.
  • Tested or not, and how.
  • Consoles and handhelds. The model, then every controller, cable and power supply that comes with it. Say whether it powers on and reads games, and whether it has been modified, opened or repaired.
  • Handhelds specifically. Screen scratches, dead pixels or lines, the battery cover, and for rechargeable models the charger and whether it holds a charge.
  • Memory cards and accessories. List them with their size where it is printed.

Leave labels and stickers as they are. Peeling off an old price sticker can take part of the label with it.

How to photograph a collection

Good photos let a buyer quote with confidence. Daylight from a window works better than a flash, which washes out labels and hides scratches.

  • One wide shot of everything, labels or spines facing the camera.
  • Close-ups of each cartridge label. Photograph the back as well if it is damaged.
  • Boxed games front and back, then opened, with the manual and inserts beside the box.
  • The playing side of each disc, tilted toward the light so scratches show.
  • Consoles from the top and the back, with the controllers and cables that come with them.
  • Handhelds with the screen on, if they power up, and the battery compartment open.
  • Anything damaged or incomplete, up close.

How to pack games and consoles for shipping

Only pack once a quote has been accepted. When it is time, these habits keep things arriving in the condition you described.

Cartridges

  • Put each loose cartridge in a small bag or sleeve so labels do not rub against each other.
  • Pack boxed games upright and snug, with padding around the stack so boxes cannot crush or slide.
  • Do not tape anything directly to a game box.

Discs

  • Make sure every disc is clipped into its case, not loose inside it.
  • Take any disc out of a console before you pack it.
  • Wrap stacks of cases so the corners and hinges are protected.

Consoles and handhelds

  • Remove batteries from handhelds, controllers and memory units before packing.
  • Wrap each console on its own, then bag the cables and controllers separately so they cannot scratch it.
  • Use a sturdy box with a few inches of padding on every side, and fill the gaps so nothing moves when you shake it.

How selling by mail to Jay’s Toys and Games works

Jay’s Toys and Games buys video games by mail, retro and modern: retro systems and games from NES through PS2, especially complete in box; modern games with the original case and art, and sealed collector’s editions; consoles; and handhelds, including Game Boy, DS, Vita and Switch. Loose games are welcome.

  1. Send a list and photos. Use the form on the sell video games page. Email photos to selling@jaystoysandgames.com.
  2. Get a quote. We reply with a quote, generally within 48 hours. It is an initial offer and it is not binding yet.
  3. Accept it in writing. Nothing ships until you have accepted the quote and its terms in writing.
  4. Ship it. Collections we value at $250 or more get a prepaid shipping label from us. The quote says up front whether shipping is covered.
  5. We check it. When the package arrives, we check that everything quoted is there and in the condition described.
  6. Sign off, get paid. If it matches, we both sign off on the final number and you are paid within 24 hours of that sign-off, by PayPal, Venmo or a mailed check. A check is mailed within 24 hours of sign-off and then takes the post to reach you, so PayPal or Venmo gets you your funds faster.
  7. If it does not match, you get a revised offer. Decline it and we send the items back, with the return shipping paid by you.

Each system has its own details worth listing. For those, see the pages for Nintendo games, PlayStation games and Sega games. For everything we buy by mail, including action figures, see Selling by mail: the overview.

Latest Stories

View all

Sunpearl Kirin and Pinnacle Starcage promo cards for the Magic: The Gathering Regional Championship Qualifier
  • 0 comments
  • by Jay's Toys & Games

Magic RCQ in Des Moines: Standard Regional Championship Qualifiers at Jay's Southside (Nov 28–29)

Two Standard Regional Championship Qualifiers at Jay's CD and Hobby Southside in Des Moines: Saturday, November 28 and Sunday, November 29, 2026 at 11:00 AM. $30 entry, 70% paid out in cash, and a Regional Championship invitation for each day's winner.

Read more

  • 0 comments
  • by Jay's Toys & Games

How to sell a retro video game collection: loose, complete in box and sealed explained

What loose, complete in box, sealed, tested and reproduction mean, how to list and photograph a collection, how to pack games and consoles safely, and how selling by mail to Jay’s Toys and Games works.

Read more

Magic: The Gathering | Star Trek key art: Sisko, Kirk, Picard, Janeway and Burnham in a rainbow transporter beam
  • 0 comments
  • by Jay's Toys & Games

Star Trek Prerelease in Des Moines & Ankeny: Set Guide and Where to Play (Nov 6–8)

Play Magic: The Gathering | Star Trek a week before release at Jay's prerelease weekend, Nov 6–8, at Southside (Des Moines) and Ankeny. What's in the set, the signed Headliner cards, how prerelease works, and how to reserve a $30 seat.

Read more

{"statementLink":"https://www.jaystoysandgames.com/pages/accessibility","footerHtml":" ","consistentHelpData":[],"hideMobile":false,"hideTrigger":false,"disableBgProcess":false,"language":"en","position":"left","leadColor":"#0e57cd","triggerColor":"#144fff","triggerRadius":"50%","triggerPositionX":"left","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerIcon":"people2","triggerSize":"medium","triggerOffsetX":20,"triggerOffsetY":20,"mobile":{"triggerSize":"medium","triggerPositionX":"left","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerOffsetX":10,"triggerOffsetY":85,"triggerRadius":"50%"}}